Savor the Best Top Italian Restaurant in Sagamore Beach

Experience the Flavors of Our Top Italian Restaurant Today

Seeking a place to indulge in authentic Italian cuisine? Look no further than our restaurant, one of the top italian restaurant spots serving the Sagamore Beach area. Enjoy classic dishes like chicken parmigiana and linguini, lovingly crafted from family recipes handed down through generations. Under the guidance of Manny Fernandez, every meal reflects our pride in using only the freshest ingredients while providing outstanding customer service. We invite you to join us for a delightful dining experience that has made us a beloved destination for families. Come visit us today and savor a taste of Italy!

ORDER ONLINE

Authentic Italian Food, From Our Family to Yours.

Since 2017, IL Montebello has been delighting guests with authentic Italian cuisine, but our story started long before that. The owner, Manny Fernandez, has dedicated his entire life to the family restaurant business. At just 14 years old, his culinary talent helped his family’s New York-based restaurant thrive. Now, decades later, Manny brings those same delicious, time-tested dishes to IL Montebello in Cape Cod.

Our focus on amazing food and unforgettable dining experiences comes from cherished family recipes, fresh ingredients, and exceptional customer service. We also keep the tradition of family ownership alive, which is why you can enjoy our heavenly dishes at the family-owned and operated Four Seasons Trattoria restaurants in Yarmouth and Hyannis on Cape Cod. Whether you’re stopping by for a meal or making a reservation, we’re happy to accommodate parties of up to 50 people!

Explore Our Delicious Italian Dining Menu

Grilled Meat, Fish, or Chicken with Salad

Grilled Steak with Salad

Grilled New York sirloin strip steak roasted to perfection with Caesar salad (or) mixed green salad.

$39.95

Grilled Chicken with Salad

Grilled chicken with Caesar salad (or) mixed green salad.

$25.95

Grilled Shrimp with Salad

Grilled shrimp with Caesar salad (or) mixed green salad. 5 jumbo shrimp.

$39.95

Grilled Salmon with Salad

Grilled salmon with Caesar salad (or) mixed green salad.

$27.95

Burgers

The Classic Burger

Beef burger with American cheese, lettuce, and tomato served with french fries.

$19.95

The Cape Cod Burger

Take a savory vacation to the islands with our fresh beef blend, American cheese topped with caramelized onions, tomato, and lettuce. Served with French fries.

$19.95

Antipasto

Mussels

In a garlic, oil, and white wine sauce or tomato sauce.

$14.95

Antipasto Caldo for 2

Baked stuffed clams, stuffed mushrooms, eggplant rollatini, and crispy baked shrimp.

$27.95

La Zuppa Della Nonna

Made in-house daily. Like Grandma used to make. 1 - Minestrone, 2 - Pasta Fagioli, or 3 - Homemade cheese tortellini in the chicken broth.

$10.95

Vongole Al Forno

Baked clams with bread crumbs, oregano, and garlic.

$12.95

Calamari Fritti

Lightly fried calamari tubes served with tomato sauce.

$12.95

Pesce / Fish

Jumbo Shrimp Any Style

Francese, Parmesan, scampi, fra diavolo.

$39.95

Sole Francaise

Pan-seared sole fillet in an egg batter with white wine, lemon, and butter.

$25.95

Salmone Mostarda

Salmon fillet finished in a Dijon mustard sauce.

$26.95

FULL MENU

Place an Online Pick-Up or Delivery Order Today!

Skip the line and order your favorite pizza, pasta, and sides online from IL Montebello. With just a few clicks, you can satisfy your cravings and enjoy a mouthwatering meal from the comfort of your own home. Order now for a taste of Italy delivered straight to your doorstep.

CALL IN

DOORDASH

It All Starts With Passion: Meet Our Chefs

The Fernandez brothers discovered their love for cooking when they were just teens. Now, all these years later, they still love to roll up their sleeves in the kitchen and greet their guests in the dining room. The secret of the decadent cuisine lies in secret family recipes that have been passed down through the years. They only use the freshest ingredients and pride themselves in bringing the food out hot and on time.

Nothing brings the chefs greater pleasure than creating food that has put a smile on faces for generations. You can find them at the IL Montebello restaurant located on the Kingsway Country Club grounds in Yarmouth. You may also stop by one of the Four Seasons Trattoria locations in Hyannis and Yarmouth.

MAKE A RESERVATION

Authentic Cuisine

We only cook authentic Italian food. Our recipes were perfected long ago and have been passed down through generations.

Our Passion

Cooking amazing food is what we know best. It brings us great pride to see our satisfied customers returning once again.

ORDER NOW

Fresh Ingredients

We use only the freshest and finest ingredients in our recipes. We also make sure to bring the food out hot and on time!

Offering the Complete Italian Dining Experience

We are your one-stop shop for all things Italian, offering a variety of dining experiences including authentic Italian cuisine, affordable meals, and exceptional catering services. Whether you’re enjoying a gourmet dine-in experience, relaxing with outdoor seating, or picking up curbside, we provide the best Italian food with a wine lounge to complement your meal.

A large house with a driveway leading to it

A group of people are sitting at tables outside on a patio.

A restaurant with tables and chairs and a bar

A group of people are sitting around a table in a room

A group of people are sitting at tables in a restaurant

A bar with a lot of bottles of alcohol on it

There are many trays of food on the table.

A pizza is sitting on a table next to a pizza cutter.

A large group of people are sitting at tables in a restaurant.

A table topped with plates of food including a pizza

A pizza and a plate of spaghetti are on a table.

A row of wine bottles sitting on top of a counter in a restaurant.

MAKE A RESERVATION

WHY CHOOSE US?

At our top italian restaurant , we redefine your dining experience with every plate served. Located near Sagamore Beach, MA, our cozy eatery invites you to indulge in traditional dishes like chicken parmigiana and linguini, prepared with love from time-honored family recipes. Since 2017, our commitment to authenticity has made us a cherished gem in the community, proving that we are indeed a top italian restaurant. Manny Fernandez and his team ensure that every guest receives exceptional service alongside their culinary creations, anchoring our restaurant as a beloved place for gatherings. Visit us soon and discover why we pride ourselves on being your go-to top italian restaurant , where flavors come alive and memories are made around the table. For more information, check out our listing on Yellow Pages or see our reviews on BBB.

What Our Satisfied Customers Have to Say

Discover what locals and visitors alike are saying about the food at IL Montebello!

Feast Your Eyes on Our Photo Gallery

Dive into our gallery to explore the mouth-watering Italian dishes, from fresh pasta to delectable pizzas. Feast your eyes and tempt your taste buds by also following us on social media.